NPCs are rude to the player even after defeating them

[szapp]

Describe the bug
NPCs confront the player when he is standing in their way even if he has defeated them before.

Expected behavior
NPCs no longer confront the player when he is standing in their way if he has defeated them before.

[catalinstoian]

gothic-1-community-patch/scriptbase/_work/Data/Scripts/Content/AI/B_Human/B_MoveNPC.d

Lines 73 to 83 in d3c811b

	else if (Npc_GetAttitude ( self, other) == ATT_ANGRY || Npc_GetAttitude ( self, other) == ATT_NEUTRAL )
	&& C_AmIStronger(self, other)
	&& !C_NpcIsGuard(self)
	&& !C_NpcIsGuardArcher(self)
	{
	B_FullStop (self);
	B_SmartTurnToNpc(self, other);
	B_Say (self, other, "$OUTOFMYWAY");
	AI_StartState (self,ZS_MoveNpcWait, 0, "");
	return;
	}

changed to

		else if	(Npc_GetAttitude ( self, other) == ATT_ANGRY || Npc_GetAttitude ( self, other) == ATT_NEUTRAL )
		&& 		C_AmIStronger(self, other)
		&& 		!C_NpcIsGuard(self)
		&& 		!C_NpcIsGuardArcher(self)
		&& 		self.aivar[AIV_WASDEFEATEDBYSC]==FALSE
		{
			B_FullStop 		(self);
			B_SmartTurnToNpc(self,	other);
			B_Say 			(self, other, "$OUTOFMYWAY");
			AI_StartState 	(self,ZS_MoveNpcWait, 0, "");	
			return;
		}

[szapp]

I suppose the label opinionated was added, because this is not really a bug but could still be regarded as an inconsistency. Looking at the code surrounding the suggested fix, I say we go forward with this “fix” as there are other circumstances in which the “move it!” comment is suppressed.

[AmProsius]

Looking at the code surrounding the suggested fix, I say we go forward with this “fix” as there are other circumstances in which the “move it!” comment is suppressed.

I agree, that's why I left the issue open.

[szapp]

The test is manual: The PC is teleported right in front of Cronos. He is set to "defeated" and should react with "May I pass through here?" instead of "Step aside!".